Hidden Paia Gem with Multi-Dwelling Potential

May 29, 2026 | Featured Listings

Just above the heart of Paia Town, 46 Puakou Place offers a rare North Shore opportunity for those seeking lifestyle, flexibility, and income potential in one compelling Maui property. Located at the quiet end of the Paia Depot Village cul-de-sac, this multi-dwelling estate combines privacy with close access to the surf, dining, boutiques, and creative energy that make Paia one of Maui’s most beloved communities.

Offered at $1,950,000, the property includes 6 bedrooms, 2 full baths, 1 half bath, and 2,052 living square feet. The main home features two mirror-image 3-bedroom, 1-bath units, extensively remodeled and soundproofed between walls to support a strong rental structure and comfortable day-to-day living.

Beyond the main residence, a detached cottage offers a private 2-bedroom, 1-bath retreat with open pasture views. This added dwelling creates valuable options for extended family, guests, long-term tenants, or owner use—making the property especially attractive for investors and lifestyle buyers alike.

With its North Shore location, multi-dwelling layout, and proven rental appeal, 46 Puakou Place stands out as a rare Paia offering. It is a property designed for those who want more than a home: they want flexibility, access, and the freedom to create a lifestyle rooted in one of Maui’s most iconic coastal communities.

46 Puakou Place invites you to experience the best of Paia living with space, privacy, and exceptional investment potential.

Property Details

46 Puakou PI, Paia, HI 96779

 

List Price

$1,950,000

Home Size

2,052 sq. ft.

Bedrooms

6

Baths

2.5

MLS

409491

Contact the listing agent

Donavan OToole | Coldwell Banker Island Properties

Kelly Kirby Lau

REALTOR® Broker
RB-24631

Discover More Featured Properties

A Timeless Kona Manor Designed for Classic Island Living

A Timeless Kona Manor Designed for Classic Island Living

On 1.75 acres of rolling lawns and manicured gardens, this red brick country manor presents a distinguished expression of Kona living. Solidly built and extensively renovated between 2014 and 2016, the residence blends classic architectural character with thoughtful modern enhancements, creating a home designed to feel refined, comfortable, and lasting.

read more
From The Heart of the Home: Inside 10 Dream Luxury Hawaii Kitchens

From The Heart of the Home: Inside 10 Dream Luxury Hawaii Kitchens

When it comes to island living, nothing quite compares to having a stunning kitchen that makes cooking, gathering, and entertaining a true delight. Today’s luxury kitchen trends are blending beauty with functionality through warmer palettes, natural wood tones, mixed finishes, smart storage solutions, and seamless smart technology integration. Explore 10 standout properties from Coldwell Banker Island Properties that showcase sophistication, comfort, and extraordinary style, designed to perfection for those who appreciate gathering around the table at the true heart of the home.

read more
Private Villa at the Andaz Maui

Private Villa at the Andaz Maui

Located along one of Maui’s most sought-after coastal corridors, 3550 Wailea Alanui Drive presents a luxury residence that balances design, comfort, and direct connection to the island’s natural surroundings.

read more